“Working To Write A Wrong”

STOP Mountaintop Removal Coal Mining

Take Action!!
Support The Clean Water Protection Act, H.R. 2169
Taking It To The House - Support Clean Water
Join the Blogger's Challenge sponsored by ilovemountains.org.




Translate to German Translate to Spanish Translate to French Translate to Italian Translate to Portuguese Translate to Japanese Translate to Korean Translate to Russian Translate to Chinese
May 16, 2008

Carbon Capture and Storage - A Good Idea?

» by Denny

Lake Monoun, West Cameroon, West Africa - In 1984 carbon dioxide (CO2) bubbled to the surface of the lake from a geothermal vent killing 37 residents in nearby villages. Two years later, 1986, a similar incident occurred also in West Africa, Lake Nyos. In this instance the lake was said to have become saturated with carbon dioxide and an underwater event, possibly landslide, caused the lake to turnover releasing a cloud of concentrated CO2 which quickly covered a 12 mile area killing 1746 people and thousands of cattle.

In coal mines - “choke damp or black damp” has been killing miners since mining began. Choke damp is pockets of concentrated CO2 underground where the air is void of any oxygen. The carbon dioxide is released directly from the coal seam.

These examples show what could happen if the carbon dioxide supposedly captured from power plants and buried underground ever gets out. If released in just small amounts it will counteract any effort of storing to reduce global warming and climate change. If it escapes in large quantities it can be deadly.

For the coal industry and the politicians in the pockets of the coal industry to be putting so much faith and trying to convince you CCS (carbon capture and storage) is a good thing without any facts to go along with their rhetoric is just deceiving.

CCS does not eliminate the problem. It takes the carbon dioxide from one place and puts it somewhere else, IF it even comes to fruition, where it is meant to stay F O R E V E R!!! It can NEVER get out or all efforts are wasted. As I have said before - anything man-made will eventually fail - it has a finite lifespan.

Clean coal technology (CCT) and carbon capture and storage (CCS) is just simply a propaganda ploy. It is meant to counteract only one thing - opposition to coal.

Invisible CO2 Gas Killing Trees at Mammoth Mountain, California

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • StumbleUpon
4
  • 1

    Wow, I didn’t know about that. Why would anyone advocate that method of storage if they knew the risks. As you so accurately said, anything manmade can fail.

    Kristine shreve on May 16th, 2008
  • 2

    Just my opinion here Kristine but I believe all they need to do is convince everyone of the possibility of storage. In doing so that gives the industry another 15 years or so of mining and burning coal without worrying about the consequences. Everybody might not agree storage is a good thing but everybody agrees it will be quite a few years before CCS is even a possibility. If it can even be done. All the clean coal talk is not worth the time taken to talk about it without CCS - but it sure sounds good and that is the point.

    Experts say we need to start reducing greenhouse gases by 2015 to curb the effects of global warming and the earliest date I have seen for CCS is 2020 and have seen estimates from 2030 to 2050. I don’t think we will ever have to worry about the carbon escaping from the ground because I don’t believe it will ever be stored.

    Amending this comment - I should have said I don’t believe CCS will ever happen on a power plant scale.

    Denny on May 17th, 2008
  • 3

    Woopee, I guess we’re all gonna die. How dumb do they think we are. Good post.

    mountainsaver on May 18th, 2008
  • 4

    So true

    storage munster on May 18th, 2008
  • Poll

    You have decided. Now it is time to decide if we need more dishonesty on the WV Supreme Court.
    You Decide 2008

  • Subscribe

  • Categories

  • Archives

  • Flickr

    Schumate HollowSchumate HollowSchumate HollowSchumate HollowSchumate HollowSchumate HollowMountaintop Removal
  • Information / Hotline


    WV DEP Main Office
    (304) 926-0440

    WV DEP Explosives and Blasting Office
    (304) 926-0490

    Spill Hotline
    1-800-642-3074

    Coal Truck Hotline
    1-866-SEE-TRUX

  • Contributing Authors

    Albert Rasch
    The Rasch Outdoor Chronicles

    BJ Gudmundsson
    Rise Up! West Virginia
    Patchwork Films

    Bluemountainmama
    Blue Mtn. Music
    Ruminations Of A Country Girl

    Brian W.
    Pennsylvania Backwoods

    Chuck Nelson
    Mountainsaver

    Denny (admin)
    The BackWoods Drifter

    Freebird - Anonymous

    Matthew Burns
    Wildlife Management Specialist
    Stop Mountaintop Removal

    Shirley Stewart Burns, Ph.D.
    Bringing Down The Mountains

  • Stats

  • Stop Mountaintop Removal, Add Your Voice

  • Spam Blocked

  • Meta